NYC Property Taxes Could Increase by 10%

New York City is considering a possible 10% property tax increase, a move that could affect both homeowners and commercial property owners. Mayor Zohran Mamdani has proposed this plan as part of efforts to close a significant budget gap. This highlights how important property taxes are in the city’s long-term financial planning and housing strategies.

‍

What's Happening?

New York City is currently facing a budget shortfall, and city officials are exploring ways to close the gap. One option under discussion is a potential 10% increase in property taxes. Mayor Mamdani has indicated that if the state government in Albany does not authorize higher income taxes on millionaires and major corporations, he may move forward with raising property taxes for all New Yorkers.

This proposed increase could affect approximately 3 million homeowners and around 100,000 businesses, potentially resulting in higher annual expenses for families and commercial property owners across the city. City officials estimate that the tax hike could generate about $3.7 billion per year, which would be directed toward essential services including public schools, police and fire departments, sanitation, and other critical city operations.

Mayor Mamdani and city leaders argue that this measure is necessary to maintain the quality of city services amid rising costs, though critics have expressed concern about the financial burden on residents and small businesses.

It’s important to note that this plan is still in the proposal stage. No decisions have been finalized. Any property tax increase would require review and approval by the City Council, and depending on state law, may also need authorization from New York State before taking effect.

‍

How Could This Affect Your Property?

For Homeowners

Even if the increase isn’t huge in dollar terms, it could impact decisions about maintaining or selling a property.

• Higher annual expenses, which could affect monthly budgets
• A potential delay in selling or buying, as carrying costs rise
• Slight shifts in property values, depending on neighborhood demand

‍

For Investors & Landlords

Higher property taxes can directly affect profits. Owners of rent-stabilized or rent-controlled apartments may not be able to pass the full increase to tenants, which means they could see lower cash flow. Some of the areas that might be impacted include:

• Cap rates - the return on investment could decrease
• Holding strategies - investors might rethink whether to keep or sell a property
• Property valuations - higher expenses can reduce the property's market value

Commercial landlords, especially those with triple-net leases, may also need to adjust rent agreements or operating budgets to cover the extra tax costs.

‍

What Can You Do To Prepare

Even though nothing has been approved yet, property owners and investors can take steps to prepare:

• Review property bills. Make sure all exemptions are applied and understand your current tax obligations.
• Plan budgets. Factor in potential tax increases into monthly and annual cash flow projections.
• Assess investments. For landlords and investors, evaluate whether higher taxes change your investment strategy or holding period.
• Stay informed. Follow updates from the City Council, Albany, and official city budget announcements.

‍

Disclaimer: This content is meant for informational purposes only and is not intended to be construed as financial, tax, legal, or insurance advice.